And if you are even slightly active on social media sites such as Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn, you have become a number too, at least in the eyes of a new breed of influence marketers.
Our numbers are being compiled, sorted, sliced, diced, priced, dissected, combined, and filleted in ways that help companies sell more of their stuff. If you are fortunate enough to have a number that is high, it might earn you a free gaming system, movie tickets, clothes, sports equipment, a vacation to Las Vegas or Europe.
If your number is low, you will receive nothing. By the way, everybody knows everybody else’s scores. They’re posted for the world to see.
This trend of social scoring is creating new classes of haves and have-nots, social media elites and losers, frenzied attempts to crash the upper class, and deepening resentments.
Social scoring is also the centerpiece of an extraordinary marketing movement. For the first time, companies can – with growing confidence – identify, quantify, and nurture valuable word-of-mouth influencers who can uniquely drive demand for their products.
Influence
The word influence used to be in the same “soft” category as love, hate, and interested. Now we’re beginning to measure it? Don Draper and his Mad Men would have loved that!
Every time I write a blog post on the subject of social scoring, my readers foam at the mouth. “The only thing that stops me from taking this seriously is that I trust my fellow citizens to oppose this as vehemently as I do,” one reader wrote. His passion sounded more like a political speech than the typical daily blog comment.
“Why don’t you take a stand and help STOP this!” another reader demanded. Stop it? Why would we want to, even if we could? What is so personally threatening about a simple ranking?
After all, common internet analytics programs already offer scads of data to determine the success of our online ads, websites, and blogs. It’s no secret that Facebook and Google keep running accounts of our every move, want, and desire with a cold completeness and unnerving efficiency that would shock even George Orwell.
We know it’s happening. We are rated and categorized constantly, and for the most part we resign ourselves to that fact. But there seems to be something dramatically different about this notion of social scoring that makes people spitting mad.
When the number crunchers twist and turn that data to evaluate people, look out! This powerful business trend is tapping into something visceral and emotional that I have not seen before.
From social proof to social scoring
Social media platforms such as Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, and Google+ are upending the traditional concept of influence. Classical models of power are being flipped around in an internet environment where nobody really knows who is who.
In our dense world of daily communication tsunamis, people yearn to find shortcuts to truth, quick reads on power, and 140-character directives to make their lives easier. The trappings of social proof implied by the number of Twitter followers or Facebook “likes” may be more important signs of accomplishment to many people than a lifetime of real achievements.
The consequences for those who seek online power and influence are vast. If you have a social media account, you are already being judged. Companies with names like Klout, PeerIndex, and Twitter Grader are in the process of scoring millions, eventually billions, of people on their level of influence.
And they’re not simply looking at the number of followers or friends you’ve amassed. They are beginning to measure online influence through extraordinarily complex algorithms tweaked daily by teams of PhD-level researchers and scientists.
They’re declaring their judgments online, too, for the entire world to see. Although being publicly rated and compared has a significant icky factor, we can’t ignore the breathtaking business opportunities.
The new influence class
When companies such as Disney, Nike, and Microsoft are creating successful marketing efforts centered on people’s social influence scores, as a business professional, you’d better take that seriously.
In essence, these companies are leveraging an entirely new marketing channel based on widespread access to personal influence. The more success these brands have, the more swag they’ll lavish on the new influence class and the hotter the fires of indignation will rage within those left behind.
We are at the dawn of the creation of a new social media caste system determined by how and when you tweet, connect, share, and comment. The haves may score better jobs, higher social status, even better luck on the dating scene.
The rules of personal power in our world have been changed forever. And there’s no turning back. How are you going to fare?
The good news is that in this new world of social influence, even the obscure, the shy, and the overlooked can become celebrities in their slice of the online world. You no longer have to win an election, be an elite athlete, or possess movie star looks to have power.
We are entering the age of the Citizen Influencer, in which every person has a chance to get behind the velvet rope and be treated like a rock star.
This is our time. This is your time.
You too can be an Internet celebrity. You too can earn your way into the influence class.
You too can discover the power of your own return on influence. And in fact, many companies already have.
This excerpt, adapted for Sparksheet, is from Return on Influence: The Revolutionary Power of Klout, Social Scoring, and Influence Marketing by Mark W. Schaefer. Copyright © 2012 by McGraw-Hill. Used by permission.




What bothers me about this is that as a reader I never feel I really know what is behind a rating from a casual user. A good newspaper movie or restaurant reviewer states his/her criteria for judging and, over time, we get to know and account for their likes and dislikes. Not necessarily so for the casual reviewer, who can write a scathing (and presumably damaging) review just because he/she was annoyed by some minor glitch.
Case in point: My son is chef at a very popular restaurant in a large East Coast city. One evening a couple came in and felt they were not seated quickly enough. The proceeded to finish their dinner and pay their bill (without tip) then went home and wrote a blistering review, critical of food and service, but with no mention of their initial gripe. But they ate everything on their plate without complaint and commented on the good service when they left. How many people did they drive away? More to the point, why should we believe them?
I believe very little of what I read from casual evaluators. Who knows what really was behind their comments — either pro or con? Who knows what are their standards for judgment, or their qualifications to judge?
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer http://t.co/dd8E8zSK
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer http://t.co/o3Q5r01r
The New Cultural Currency…Social Influence
: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer http://t.co/I3LDexet
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer http://t.co/VTsffy6D
#Influence matters but #loyalty and lifetime value matter more. http://t.co/HlPuV9l4
#sparksheet Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer http://t.co/d1XIqPOd
#SMspark Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer http://t.co/JzL8Cs3u #SM24hrs
Does the return of influence signal the end of innocence? http://t.co/fey8vSeB cc: @markwschaefer #yam
RT @sparksheet: Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer http://t.co/n8cVMcRf
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer http://t.co/vKHR5oBL
These aren't your grandfather's readership numbers… Return on Influence: Rise of the Citizen Influencer | Sparksheet: http://t.co/f3WC4fLq
Social Media scoring creates new class of haves & have-nots: Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer http://t.co/Aaw6HIT5
What's your influence? ———–> Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer | Sparksheet: http://t.co/lo2yP1zn
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer | Sparksheet: http://t.co/8luiEpcb
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer | Sparksheet: http://t.co/KVDCS4w5
Social media analysis: influence is the currency of social. http://t.co/GucpthYL
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer | Sparksheet http://t.co/lfnm69Zy Interesting Read!
Excellent book that I'm currently reading. I highly recommend it! http://t.co/Ic4ApoQW
A piece on online influence: "The rules of personal power in our world have been changed forever."| Sparksheet: http://t.co/zZ4g7vPr.
A piece on online influence: "The rules of personal power in our world have been changed forever."| Sparksheet: http://t.co/zZ4g7vPr.
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer via @markwschaefer http://t.co/qduMPxnR
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer via @markwschaefer http://t.co/qduMPxnR
RT @Britopian: Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer via @markwschaefer http://t.co/57sxVhSS – great read!!
READING: Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer http://t.co/KXlZjYBw
This looks great: Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer via @markwschaefer http://t.co/efVZkBDA #sm @suxsam
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer http://t.co/dY1U6SQ1
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer http://t.co/Fhic5XsO
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer | Sparksheet: http://t.co/z0xTIeWg
Return on #Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer via @Sparksheet http://t.co/nASEwDrr
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer – http://t.co/ZC2v8tNO
People power: a piece on the new citizen influencer and how they are turning the marketing tables http://t.co/pmovnE7K
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer – http://t.co/uUa8OR5Y
Read this book. Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer | Sparksheet: http://t.co/hIYR30bN
Read this book fellas. http://t.co/VYUheNGU
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer | Sparksheet: http://t.co/dghliL7K
Return on Influence: The Rise of the Citizen Influencer | Sparksheet: http://t.co/dghliL7K
[...] Spam and commercialism did their share to diminish this spirit of giving, but it didn’t go away altogether – it’s alive and well in social media. And it is one of the most powerful forces in influence. [...]
Return on #Influence: the currency of our times http://t.co/6MuFtMvw
[...] changed more in the last decade than it did in the previous five decades combined. The shift in the information balance between buyer and seller is like nothing we’ve ever seen [...]